Watch Kyra Sedgwick And Matthew Broderick Scandalize Andy Cohen On Watch What Happens Live

Apparently they dated in high school...OR DID THEY?! (They did.) (Maybe?)

I can't tell for total sure that Kyra Sedgwick and Matthew Broderick really did date on and off in high school like they claimed on last night's WWHL, tbh. Broderick protests that he doesn't want to put a label on it, which makes me think the whole thing's a put-on, but on the other hand, the incest-y "relationship" patterns of theater kids kind of mean it's possible that they both did...and didn't.

They did go to high school together, though (along with Manchester By The Sea's Kenneth Lonergan, as I just learned in a New Yorker article everyone else probably read weeks ago), and whatever happened, Andy's "WUT." face is as reliably satisfying as always.