Photo: Comedy Central, ABC

Yahweh Or No Way vs. Dana and Casey Kiss

It's Stephen Colbert's Most Catholicest Moment vs. a slow burn smoochy payoff!

224 votes

Yahweh Or No Way

154 votes

Dana and Casey Kiss

The case for Yahweh Or No Way

As the self-proclaimed most famous Roman Catholic in America, Stephen (the first martyr of Christianity) Colbert discussed many issues related to his religion on The Colbert Report, including: reciting the Nicene Creed, performing an interpretive liturgical dance to King of Glory, examining Pope Francis' secret life as a superhero, and having a Catholic trivia throwdown with Jack White. Topping that highlight reel were Stephen's remarks after the resignation of Pope Benedict, including who might be on deck to replace him. Was Stephen being bitingly funny? Of course. Was he also sincere in his bewilderment? Could be! — palmaire

The case for Dana and Casey Kiss

It is not at all possible to write a workplace-based TV series without office romance, but all shows should do them as well as Sports Night. Viewers knew Casey and Dana belonged together, and sparks simmered, but it took until the second season premiere for anything to happen. After chronic dithering and several failed attempts to ask her out, Casey finally goes all in and kisses her like he's going off to war. It was the perfect payoff. — LJD

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard