Photo: NBC,

The Kelly Song vs. If I Didn't Have You

It's Woody's creative declaration of love vs. Howard's song for Bernadette!

202 votes

The Kelly Song

148 votes

If I Didn't Have You

The case for The Kelly Song

Woody was a simple man. He tended bar, he didn't have high ambitions and he loved his fiancee Kelly. So much so that he wrote her a song as simple as he was. Just admit know you still sing this to yourself every time you meet someone named Kelly. Maybe even out loud. — Nutjob

The case for If I Didn't Have You

On the anniversary of their first date, Howard writes a song for Bernadette, and everyone ends up singing it to her in the hospital after she gets quarantined for exposure to raccoon virus. It's a touching, nerd-filled tune that proves that Simon Helberg is the best part of The Big Bang Theory. — Lela

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard