Photo: Fox, Will Heath / NBC

'Piece By Piece' vs. David S. Pumpkins

It's Kelly Clarkson making everyone cry vs. a classic Halloween scare!

672 votes

'Piece By Piece'

345 votes

David S. Pumpkins

The case for 'Piece By Piece'

On the final season of American Idol, the first ever idol returned back to do some judging of the current contestants, but the real moment for her was when she sang "Piece by Piece"...and then, well let's just say, it looks like Keith will never stop crying. And you probably won't either. — Bee

The case for David S. Pumpkins

What can even be said to make a case? What needs to be said? It's David S. Pumpkins! — Bee

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard