Photo: Comedy Central, The WB

Mr. Garvey's Roll Call vs. The Class Protector Parasol

It's discovering where A-A-Ron is vs. Buffy's umbrella award!

513 votes

Mr. Garvey's Roll Call

498 votes

The Class Protector Parasol

The case for Mr. Garvey's Roll Call

It doesn't get much better than Mr. Garvey, who taught school in the inner city for 20 years, taking attendance as a substitute teacher. If you're not careful, you could get sent to Principal O-Shag-Henessy's office for being insubordinate and churlish. — cynicat

The case for The Class Protector Parasol

The Slayer is used to not getting any credit, it's part of the whole 'secret identity' gig. So when Jonathan announced that the Class of '95 (lowest mortality rate of any graduating class in Sunnydale history!) voted to give Buffy a special award, "Class Protector", the waterworks opened. One look at Buffy smiling with that sparkly pink parasol and...Shut up, you're crying! — Stephanie R

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard