Photo: NBC,

HOF: The Great Herring War vs. HOF: Picture It: Sicily 1904

It's the best St. Olaf tale vs. Sophia Petrillo's trusty tall-tale intro!

34%
73 votes

HOF: The Great Herring War

66%
141 votes

HOF: Picture It: Sicily 1904

The case for HOF: The Great Herring War

In the first season finale of The Golden Girls, we get to see how Rose and Dorothy came to live in Blanche's too-big-for-just-her Miami home. But nothing could have prepared us for Rose's best (and first ever) story about St. Olaf — Drogo

The case for HOF: Picture It: Sicily 1904

The years varied (1904; 1912; in this clip, an 1850s tale from before Sophia was born involving a...pool party?), but Sophia Petrillo's tall tales all shared a few key components, including how hot she was before the Great War...and of course the exhortation to her listeners to "Picture it..." — Sarah D. Bunting


Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard

Discussion

Explore the Television forum or add a comment below.