Photo: CBS, Fox

Darlene Love's Last Late Show Christmas vs. Bart Simpson's Tragic Marshmallow

It's a Christmas baby we didn't want to go vs. a hot chocolate sponge!

158 votes

Darlene Love's Last Late Show Christmas

118 votes

Bart Simpson's Tragic Marshmallow

The case for Darlene Love's Last Late Show Christmas

When David Letterman was the host of The Late Show on CBS, he had a few holiday traditions. He'd have a Christmas tree in the studio with a giant meatball in place of an angel or star. He'd have actor Jay Thomas on to tell the Lone Ranger story. And he'd close things out with Darlene Love singing "Christmas (Baby Please Don't Go." We all knew 2014 was going to be Love's last chance to wow Letterman -- and us. And wow, did she ever. — Tara Ariano

The case for Bart Simpson's Tragic Marshmallow

An unexpected consequence of Bart's getting caught shoplifting right before Christmas? Marge deciding he wasn't her special little guy anymore and letting him do some things for himself. Unfortunately, he wasn't quite ready for all that responsibility. — Tara Ariano

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard