Photo: ABC, Fox

"Dad's Dead!" vs. Bob's Horrible Memory

It's comedy = tragedy + time + Laurie Metcalf doing her thing on the phone vs. a restaurateur who's not so good with dates!

325 votes

"Dad's Dead!"

147 votes

Bob's Horrible Memory

The case for "Dad's Dead!"

Jackie straining for clarity amid grief. — Joe Reid

The case for Bob's Horrible Memory

Bob Belcher is a busy man! He can't be bothered to keep track of silly things like birthdays! — Jenn Brasler

Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard


Explore the Television forum or add a comment below.