Daddy's Boy vs. Richard Hatch's Aztek
It's the 1938 Harrison von Harrison Jr. musical vs. Survivor's first cursed car!
Richard Hatch's Aztek
The case for Daddy's Boy
After one of Kimmy Schmidt's love interests, Logan, spends the "Kimmy's in a Love Triangle" episode describing himself in passing as a "Daddy's Boy," the throwaway jokes come to a head when we get to see this fabulous closing scene from from the musical he's been referencing.
The case for Richard Hatch's Aztek
The Survivor car curse was something of a running joke, though not for the winner of each vehicle as none of them managed to win the ultimate title. But I feel the curse really started when Richard Hatch won his car and title at the same time. Now, one can argue that what happened to Richard after his win (his jail time for tax evasion, his weight gain/appearance on The Biggest Loser) was of his own doing. But I'd like to think that that car had some role in what happened.
I mean, look at it. It is one ugly, evil car.