Photo: NBC, ABC

Carter and Lucy Get Stabbed vs. Goth Vaughn

It's a terrifying ER cliffhanger vs. a CIA operative's unfortunate foray into guyliner!

64%
348 votes

Carter and Lucy Get Stabbed

36%
192 votes

Goth Vaughn

The case for Carter and Lucy Get Stabbed

ER had many dramatic and memorable moments over the years, but one of its scariest was at the end of a February 2000 episode, when schizophrenic but not-yet-diagnosed Paul (played by guest star David Krumholtz) has a rough day at the ER and strikes out at his doctors in this cliffhanger ending. — EllieH

The case for Goth Vaughn

Why this wasn't the sole focus of the revamped opening credit sequence in season four, I just cannot understand.— Ryan W


Submit Challenger

View Leaderboard

Discussion

Explore the Television forum or add a comment below.